Mama Witch is busy making a special treat for her Picky Little Witch. A witch’s brew filled with all kinds of awful ingredients, from eye of newt to hair of slug. The list goes on and on across several pages, each more disgusting than the last. The Picky Little Witch mimics the reader’s own thoughts, yuck, gross and even barf! She comes up with many different excuses why she can’t try the witch’s stew, but Mama Witch has a clever solution for each one. Eventually, the Picky Little Witch tries the stew and to her and our surprise, she actually loves it!
Then it’s time for trick-or-treating! Mama Witch watches the Picky Little Witch collect all kinds of goodies. From candy apples to licorice snakes. As the Picky Little Witch’s excitement mounts so does Mama Witch’s disgust. The Picky Little Witch encourages her mom to try some of these delectable Halloween treats, and she refuses, much like her daughter earlier in the story. She offers up many excuses, but her daughter refutes each one. Talk about role reversals. Mama Witch ends up loving the sweet treats as much as the Picky Little Witch loved the witch’s brew. In the end, they learn that trying new things isn’t all scary.
The Picky Little Witch by Elizabeth Brokamp is great for kids ages 5-8.